Welcome to Fitzy's Cafe

“ Fitzy’s has the best specialty lattes, house made pastries, and wholesome and delicious food menu. It also has an amazing seating environment and ambience. The owners really care and it shows in everything from the products to the service! ”

“ Absolute gem. One of the best cappuccinos I’ve ever had. Super cute interior with plenty of seating options. Highly recommended for snagging a coffee with friends or getting a little work done. Will definitely be returning! ”

“ Fitzy’s Cafe is a gem! The moment I walked in, I was struck by the vibrant, welcoming atmosphere - full of energy yet cozy enough to sit back and enjoy. The drinks were absolutely scrumptious, crafted with care and a surprising level of finesse. A special shoutout goes to the high school barista, whose skill and friendliness made the experience even more memorable. Their attention to detail and enthusiasm for their craft truly elevated my visit. I absolutely adored everything about this spot and will be coming back soon. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a place with both excellent drinks and an uplifting vibe! ”

“ Don’t let the outside fool you! We came based on the reviews but thought we were at the wrong place at first - this is a luncheonette shared with a local pharmacy and gift shop. You order at the counter and they’ll bring your food to you. With both table seating, counter seating looking out the window and outdoor seating (weather permitting), there are plenty of spaces to choose from. This is a charming spot in Whitefish Bay and almost feels like you’ve stepped back in time. Really sweet! We ordered the chicken salad sandwich and tuna fish melt. Both delicious - the tuna fish melt came with red grapes in the tuna salad - unique but tasty surprise. The chicken salad was also good - could have been a more generous serving, but delicious nonetheless. Very generous side salad. Give yourself time to look around the gift shop area and pharmacy - we picked up Milwaukee postcards and some cool soap products, great card and baby gift selection (I’ve included a few pics of the products, because we are always looking for quaint items and have put this as a reminder to come when shopping for gifts for holidays or friends birthdays) As we left we tried the ice cream and it was worth the calories:) a couple of unique flavors. Everyone is really nice - especially the pharmacy guys! Very charming little spot. ”

“ I recently discovered Fitzy’s Cafe after having a disappointing experience in the area. This cafe is top notch. First the ambiance, don’t be startled if you come in from the back and see a pharmacy, this is what makes this space so unique. It’s a one stop shop for many needs. Next, the hospitality. The staff here is the gold standard of customer service. Attentive, knowledgeable, and friendly, oh, and very accommodating. Finally the coffee and food. The barista and bakers knowledge and care for the craft is exceptional. If you want a delicious and beautifully made coffee, made with care, love, and appreciation for every detail, stop by Fitzy’s you will not be disappointed. Oh, the pastries are to die for, fresh, warm, delicate. Yum! ”

“ Ive been picking up my medications here for over two years. The staff is very friendly and I occasionally pick up a cookie or coffee from the cafe. I highly recommend a stop if you are in the area. They are far more professional than Walgreens or CVS. ”

“ I am SO glad that Fitzy’s Cafe is back at Fitzgerald’s Pharmacy! The food is excellent and very high quality. I highly recommend the avocado toast when it’s on the menu, the grilled cheese, chocolate chip cookie (warmed up), hot chocolate, and the ice cream! Everything we’ve had is terrific and flavorful. The cafe is such a hidden gem nestled inside the pharmacy. We are lucky to have this small business a part of our community, and we are happy to support their local cafe and the pharmacy as well. In addition to the delicious food, the team working there is extremely friendly, helpful, kind, and hardworking. I highly recommend you give them a try. You won’t regret it! ”

“ Coming from another state to visit family here it's not often you'd find a cafe that serves halal while having astounding atmosphere. The cafe Manager here and her new employee warmly greeted us and recommended their popular food and drink item. We went with the Beef Melt and Toasted Marzipan latte that was top quality and worth the price. Meals are on the pricier end however you do get portion and quality that matches the price. Highly recommend to visit here to get refreshed, eat good, grab coffee and go about your day! Shout-out to Eat Halal MKE for sharing this place on their IG page~ ”